Keeping Church History Safe: Bulletins, Photos, and Records
Ask The Office is where I answer the questions about running the church office. Here is this week's.
"Our church is almost 100 years old and we have boxes of old bulletins plus years of files on our computers. How do we keep all of it so the church history is not lost?"
Decide what is worth keeping, save it in a standard format such as PDF, and keep at least one copy somewhere other than the church building. Then give one person the job of looking after it every year.
Why church records matter
A church's bulletins, minutes, programs, anniversary books, and photographs are its memory. Software changes, computers fail, and volunteers move on. A record that is not looked after on purpose is usually a record that disappears. If you have already read Publisher's Gone. Are Ten Years of Bulletins Gone Too?, this is the next step: not rescuing old files, but keeping them for history.
You do not have to guess at the best way to do this. Denominational archives and church insurance companies have published guidance, and what follows draws on that. The sources are listed at the end.
How to do it: build a simple archive
- Decide what to keep. Archivists agree on the top of the list. The Presbyterian Historical Society calls the minutes the single most important thing a church creates. Next come annual reports, membership and baptism records, bylaws, directories, newsletters, anniversary and dedication materials, and photographs with names and dates written on them.
- Be choosy with bulletins. Archivists do not all agree here. United Methodist guidance lists Sunday and special-occasion bulletins as permanent. Presbyterian and Reformed archivists keep the special occasions and a sample of ordinary Sundays. A sensible middle path is to keep every special-occasion bulletin and at least a few Sundays from each year. If you are a part of a denominational body, find out what your specific requirements are.
- Pick a simple folder plan. One main folder named for the archive, then folders by year, then by type: bulletins, programs, photos, minutes. Use plain names with underscores instead of spaces, and put a short note in each folder saying what is in it.
- Save as PDF. The Library of Congress and the archives of the Episcopal and United Methodist churches all point to PDF, and PDF/A, a version built for long-term archiving, is the preferred form. Ask whether your software can export "PDF/A."
- Scan the paper, then keep the originals. Scan old bulletins and programs and give each file a name with the date, such as 1998-05-10-bulletin.pdf. The Episcopal archives specifically warn against throwing away important originals after scanning. Store them in acid-free boxes and folders, with no tape or sticky notes.
- Keep three copies in two kinds of places, one away from the building. Archivists and librarians call this the 3-2-1 rule: three copies, on two different kinds of storage, with one stored somewhere else. The church insurer Brotherhood Mutual gives the same advice for records, and notes that digital records are much more likely to survive a disaster than paper. For the off-site copy, use an external drive kept in a bank safe deposit box, or a cloud account owned by the church and not by one person.
- Name a keeper. United Methodist guidance calls for a church historian and a small records committee. Episcopal guidance calls for a records coordinator. The title does not matter and your church may have it's own named position. However, you do it, you want to name one volunteer or small team to own the archive process and add the new year each January.
What trips people up
The most common problem is that the files live on one person's personal computer or account. Church records belong to the church, not to an individual, so when that person moves or retires, the history should not go with them. The second problem is a backup that sits in the same room as the original, which does not help in a fire or a flood.
The third problem is quieter. Storage does not last forever. United Methodist archivists note that hard drives and similar media last about twenty-five years at best, and they advise moving records to new storage when technology changes. Some archivists are also cautious about relying on the cloud alone for records you must never lose, which is why the plan above keeps more than one kind of copy. Finally, think before scanning anything that names children or private pastoral matters. The Presbyterian Historical Society cautions against scanning or sharing records where accidental exposure could harm people. Documenting for posterity shouldn't supercede protecting a family's privacy for generations to come.
The office shortcut: a January habit
Each January, take thirty minutes to an hour to review. Save the previous year's bulletins, the minutes, the annual report, and a few good photographs into the archive folder. Then open a few files from each copy to be sure they still open, and confirm who the keeper is. Small and steady beats a big project that never starts.
The bottom line
You do not need special software to protect your history. You need a short list of what matters, a standard file format, a second copy off site, and at least one faithful person. This post is about history, not legal or tax records, so ask your treasurer or an attorney how long to keep financial and employment papers. Your own denomination's archives are also worth a call, since many will answer questions about local church records at no charge. Have a question of your own? Send it to us, and it may become a future Ask The Office.
Where this advice comes from
- Presbyterian Historical Society, "What is and isn't a matter of record"
- United Methodist General Commission on Archives and History, Guidelines for Managing Records of the Local Church
- United Methodist General Commission on Archives and History, Guidelines for Managing Digital Records
- Archives of the Episcopal Church, Electronic Records FAQ
- Archives of the Episcopal Church, Guidelines for Parish Archives with Limited Resources
- Reformed Church in America, Record Retention Guidelines
- Southern Baptist Historical Library and Archives, vital church records
- Louisiana Baptists, "What Do I Keep?"
- Brotherhood Mutual, Records Retention for Ministries
- Library of Congress, Recommended Formats Statement
- University of Michigan Library, Personal Digital Archiving Guide (the 3-2-1 rule)
Got a question for The Office? Reply to The Church Office newsletter and it might show up here. The Church Office is a weekly note on technology and AI for the people who keep the church running. One useful thing a week, in plain language, that you can do yourself.